1
//! Code to handle incoming cells on a channel.
2
//!
3
//! The role of this code is to run in a separate asynchronous task,
4
//! and routes cells to the right circuits.
5
//!
6
//! TODO: I have zero confidence in the close-and-cleanup behavior here,
7
//! or in the error handling behavior.
8

            
9
use super::circmap::{CircEnt, CircMap};
10
use crate::circuit::CircuitRxSender;
11
use crate::client::circuit::halfcirc::HalfCirc;
12
use crate::client::circuit::padding::{
13
    PaddingController, PaddingEvent, PaddingEventStream, SendPadding, StartBlocking,
14
};
15
use crate::util::err::ReactorError;
16
use crate::util::oneshot_broadcast;
17
use crate::{Error, HopNum, Result};
18
use tor_async_utils::SinkPrepareExt as _;
19
use tor_cell::chancell::ChanMsg;
20
use tor_cell::chancell::msg::{Destroy, DestroyReason, Padding, PaddingNegotiate};
21
use tor_cell::chancell::{AnyChanCell, CircId, msg::AnyChanMsg};
22
use tor_error::debug_report;
23
use tor_rtcompat::{CoarseTimeProvider, DynTimeProvider, SleepProvider};
24

            
25
#[cfg_attr(not(target_os = "linux"), allow(unused))]
26
use tor_error::error_report;
27
#[cfg_attr(not(target_os = "linux"), allow(unused))]
28
use tor_rtcompat::StreamOps;
29

            
30
use futures::channel::mpsc;
31
use oneshot_fused_workaround as oneshot;
32

            
33
use futures::Sink;
34
use futures::StreamExt as _;
35
use futures::sink::SinkExt;
36
use futures::stream::Stream;
37
use futures::{select, select_biased};
38
use tor_error::internal;
39

            
40
use std::fmt;
41
use std::pin::Pin;
42
use std::sync::Arc;
43

            
44
use crate::channel::{ChannelDetails, CloseInfo, kist::KistParams, padding, params::*, unique_id};
45
use crate::circuit::celltypes::CreateResponse;
46
use tracing::{debug, instrument, trace};
47

            
48
/// A boxed trait object that can provide `ChanCell`s.
49
pub(super) type BoxedChannelStream =
50
    Box<dyn Stream<Item = std::result::Result<AnyChanCell, Error>> + Send + Unpin + 'static>;
51
/// A boxed trait object that can sink `ChanCell`s.
52
pub(super) type BoxedChannelSink =
53
    Box<dyn Sink<AnyChanCell, Error = Error> + Send + Unpin + 'static>;
54
/// A boxed trait object that can provide additional `StreamOps` on a `BoxedChannelStream`.
55
pub(super) type BoxedChannelStreamOps = Box<dyn StreamOps + Send + Unpin + 'static>;
56
/// The type of a oneshot channel used to inform reactor users of the result of an operation.
57
pub(super) type ReactorResultChannel<T> = oneshot::Sender<Result<T>>;
58

            
59
cfg_if::cfg_if! {
60
    if #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding")] {
61
        use crate::util::sink_blocker::{SinkBlocker, CountingPolicy};
62
        /// Type used by a channel reactor to send cells to the network.
63
        pub(super) type ChannelOutputSink = SinkBlocker<BoxedChannelSink, CountingPolicy>;
64
    } else {
65
        /// Type used by a channel reactor to send cells to the network.
66
        pub(super) type ChannelOutputSink = BoxedChannelSink;
67
    }
68
}
69

            
70
/// A message telling the channel reactor to do something.
71
#[cfg_attr(docsrs, doc(cfg(feature = "testing")))]
72
#[derive(Debug)]
73
#[allow(unreachable_pub)] // Only `pub` with feature `testing`; otherwise, visible in crate
74
#[allow(clippy::exhaustive_enums, private_interfaces)]
75
pub enum CtrlMsg {
76
    /// Shut down the reactor.
77
    Shutdown,
78
    /// Tell the reactor that a given circuit has gone away.
79
    CloseCircuit(CircId),
80
    /// Allocate a new circuit in this channel's circuit map, generating an ID for it
81
    /// and registering senders for messages received for the circuit.
82
    AllocateCircuit {
83
        /// Channel to send the circuit's `CreateResponse` down.
84
        created_sender: oneshot::Sender<CreateResponse>,
85
        /// Channel to send other messages from this circuit down.
86
        sender: CircuitRxSender,
87
        /// Oneshot channel to send the new circuit's identifiers down.
88
        tx: ReactorResultChannel<(
89
            CircId,
90
            crate::circuit::UniqId,
91
            PaddingController,
92
            PaddingEventStream,
93
        )>,
94
    },
95
    /// Enable/disable/reconfigure channel padding
96
    ///
97
    /// The sender of these messages is responsible for the optimisation of
98
    /// ensuring that "no-change" messages are elided.
99
    /// (This is implemented in `ChannelsParamsUpdatesBuilder`.)
100
    ///
101
    /// These updates are done via a control message to avoid adding additional branches to the
102
    /// main reactor `select!`.
103
    ConfigUpdate(Arc<ChannelPaddingInstructionsUpdates>),
104
    /// Enable/disable/reconfigure KIST.
105
    ///
106
    /// Like in the case of `ConfigUpdate`,
107
    /// the sender of these messages is responsible for the optimisation of
108
    /// ensuring that "no-change" messages are elided.
109
    KistConfigUpdate(KistParams),
110
    /// Change the current padding implementation to the one provided.
111
    #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding-manual")]
112
    SetChannelPadder {
113
        /// The padder to install, or None to remove any existing padder.
114
        padder: Option<crate::client::CircuitPadder>,
115
        /// A oneshot channel to use in reporting the outcome.
116
        sender: oneshot::Sender<Result<()>>,
117
    },
118
}
119

            
120
/// Object to handle incoming cells and background tasks on a channel.
121
///
122
/// This type is returned when you finish a channel; you need to spawn a
123
/// new task that calls `run()` on it.
124
#[must_use = "If you don't call run() on a reactor, the channel won't work."]
125
pub struct Reactor<S: SleepProvider + CoarseTimeProvider> {
126
    /// Underlying runtime we use for generating sleep futures and telling time.
127
    pub(super) runtime: S,
128
    /// A receiver for control messages from `Channel` objects.
129
    pub(super) control: mpsc::UnboundedReceiver<CtrlMsg>,
130
    /// A oneshot sender that is used to alert other tasks when this reactor is
131
    /// finally dropped.
132
    pub(super) reactor_closed_tx: oneshot_broadcast::Sender<Result<CloseInfo>>,
133
    /// A receiver for cells to be sent on this reactor's sink.
134
    ///
135
    /// `Channel` objects have a sender that can send cells here.
136
    pub(super) cells: super::CellRx,
137
    /// A Stream from which we can read `ChanCell`s.
138
    ///
139
    /// This should be backed by a TLS connection if you want it to be secure.
140
    pub(super) input: futures::stream::Fuse<BoxedChannelStream>,
141
    /// A Sink to which we can write `ChanCell`s.
142
    ///
143
    /// This should also be backed by a TLS connection if you want it to be secure.
144
    pub(super) output: ChannelOutputSink,
145
    /// A handler for setting stream options on the underlying stream.
146
    #[cfg_attr(not(target_os = "linux"), allow(unused))]
147
    pub(super) streamops: BoxedChannelStreamOps,
148
    /// Timer tracking when to generate channel padding.
149
    ///
150
    /// Note that this is _distinct_ from the experimental maybenot-based padding
151
    /// implemented with padding_ctrl and padding_stream.
152
    /// This is the existing per-channel padding
153
    /// in the tor protocol used to resist netflow attacks.
154
    pub(super) padding_timer: Pin<Box<padding::Timer<S>>>,
155
    /// Outgoing cells introduced at the channel reactor
156
    pub(super) special_outgoing: SpecialOutgoing,
157
    /// A map from circuit ID to Sinks on which we can deliver cells.
158
    pub(super) circs: CircMap,
159
    /// A unique identifier for this channel.
160
    pub(super) unique_id: super::UniqId,
161
    /// Information shared with the frontend
162
    pub(super) details: Arc<ChannelDetails>,
163
    /// Context for allocating unique circuit log identifiers.
164
    pub(super) circ_unique_id_ctx: unique_id::CircUniqIdContext,
165
    /// A padding controller to which padding-related events should be reported.
166
    ///
167
    /// (This is used for experimental maybenot-based padding.)
168
    //
169
    // TODO: It would be good to use S here instead of DynTimeProvider,
170
    // but we still need the latter for the clones of padding_ctrl that we hand out
171
    // inside ChannelSender.
172
    pub(super) padding_ctrl: PaddingController<DynTimeProvider>,
173
    /// An event stream telling us about padding-related events.
174
    ///
175
    /// (This is used for experimental maybenot-based padding.)
176
    pub(super) padding_event_stream: PaddingEventStream<DynTimeProvider>,
177
    /// If present, the current rules for blocking the output based on the padding framework.
178
    pub(super) padding_blocker: Option<StartBlocking>,
179
    /// What link protocol is the channel using?
180
    #[allow(dead_code)] // We don't support protocols where this would matter
181
    pub(super) link_protocol: u16,
182
}
183

            
184
/// Outgoing cells introduced at the channel reactor
185
#[derive(Default, Debug, Clone)]
186
pub(super) struct SpecialOutgoing {
187
    /// If we must send a `PaddingNegotiate`, this is present.
188
    padding_negotiate: Option<PaddingNegotiate>,
189
    /// A number of pending PADDING cells that we have to send, once there is space.
190
    n_padding: u16,
191
}
192

            
193
impl SpecialOutgoing {
194
    /// Do we have a special cell to send?
195
    ///
196
    /// Called by the reactor before looking for cells from the reactor's clients.
197
    /// The returned message *must* be sent by the caller, not dropped!
198
    #[must_use = "SpecialOutgoing::next()'s return value must be actually sent"]
199
5056
    fn next(&mut self) -> Option<AnyChanCell> {
200
        // If this gets more cases, consider making SpecialOutgoing into a #[repr(C)]
201
        // enum, so that we can fast-path the usual case of "no special message to send".
202
5056
        if let Some(p) = self.padding_negotiate.take() {
203
            return Some(p.into());
204
5056
        }
205
5056
        if self.n_padding > 0 {
206
            self.n_padding -= 1;
207
            return Some(Padding::new().into());
208
5056
        }
209
5056
        None
210
5056
    }
211

            
212
    /// Try to queue a padding cell to be sent.
213
    fn queue_padding_cell(&mut self) {
214
        self.n_padding = self.n_padding.saturating_add(1);
215
    }
216
}
217

            
218
/// Allows us to just say debug!("{}: Reactor did a thing", &self, ...)
219
///
220
/// There is no risk of confusion because no-one would try to print a
221
/// Reactor for some other reason.
222
impl<S: SleepProvider + CoarseTimeProvider> fmt::Display for Reactor<S> {
223
1064
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut fmt::Formatter) -> fmt::Result {
224
1064
        fmt::Debug::fmt(&self.unique_id, f)
225
1064
    }
226
}
227

            
228
impl<S: SleepProvider + CoarseTimeProvider> Reactor<S> {
229
    /// Launch the reactor, and run until the channel closes or we
230
    /// encounter an error.
231
    ///
232
    /// Once this function returns, the channel is dead, and can't be
233
    /// used again.
234
    #[instrument(level = "trace", skip_all)]
235
402
    pub async fn run(mut self) -> Result<()> {
236
        trace!(channel_id = %self, "Running reactor");
237
        let result: Result<()> = loop {
238
            match self.run_once().await {
239
                Ok(()) => (),
240
                Err(ReactorError::Shutdown) => break Ok(()),
241
                Err(ReactorError::Err(e)) => break Err(e),
242
            }
243
        };
244

            
245
        // Log that the reactor stopped, possibly with the associated error as a report.
246
        // May log at a higher level depending on the error kind.
247
        const MSG: &str = "Reactor stopped";
248
        match &result {
249
            Ok(()) => debug!(channel_id = %self, "{MSG}"),
250
            Err(e) => debug_report!(e, channel_id = %self, "{MSG}"),
251
        }
252

            
253
        // Inform any waiters that the channel has closed.
254
        let close_msg = result.as_ref().map_err(Clone::clone).map(|()| CloseInfo);
255
        self.reactor_closed_tx.send(close_msg);
256
        result
257
312
    }
258

            
259
    /// Helper for run(): handles only one action.
260
    #[instrument(level = "trace", skip_all)]
261
5292
    async fn run_once(&mut self) -> std::result::Result<(), ReactorError> {
262
        select! {
263

            
264
            // See if the output sink can have cells written to it yet.
265
            // If so, see if we have to-be-transmitted cells.
266
5010
            ret = self.output.prepare_send_from(async {
267
                // This runs if we will be able to write, so try to obtain a cell:
268

            
269
5010
                if let Some(l) = self.special_outgoing.next() {
270
                    // See reasoning below.
271
                    // eprintln!("PADDING - SENDING NEOGIATION: {:?}", &l);
272
                    self.padding_timer.as_mut().note_cell_sent();
273
                    return Some((l, None));
274
5010
                }
275

            
276
5010
                select_biased! {
277
5010
                    n = self.cells.next() => {
278
                        // Note transmission on *input* to the reactor, not ultimate
279
                        // transmission.  Ideally we would tap into the TCP stream at the far
280
                        // end of our TLS or perhaps during encoding on entry to the TLS, but
281
                        // both of those would involve quite some plumbing.  Doing it here in
282
                        // the reactor avoids additional inter-task communication, mutexes,
283
                        // etc.  (And there is no real difference between doing it here on
284
                        // input, to just below, on enquieing into the `sendable`.)
285
                        //
286
                        // Padding is sent when the output channel is idle, and the effect of
287
                        // buffering is just that we might sent it a little early because we
288
                        // measure idleness when we last put something into the output layers.
289
                        //
290
                        // We can revisit this if measurement shows it to be bad in practice.
291
                        //
292
                        // (We in any case need padding that we generate when idle to make it
293
                        // through to the output promptly, or it will be late and ineffective.)
294
4454
                        self.padding_timer.as_mut().note_cell_sent();
295
4454
                        n
296
                    },
297
5010
                    p = self.padding_timer.as_mut().next() => {
298
                        // eprintln!("PADDING - SENDING PADDING: {:?}", &p);
299

            
300
                        // Note that we treat padding from the padding_timer as a normal cell,
301
                        // since it doesn't have a padding machine.
302
                        self.padding_ctrl.queued_data(HopNum::from(0));
303

            
304
                        self.padding_timer.as_mut().note_cell_sent();
305
                        Some((p.into(), None))
306
                    },
307
                }
308
4454
            }) => {
309
                self.padding_ctrl.flushed_channel_cell();
310
                let (queued, sendable) = ret?;
311
                let (msg, cell_padding_info) = queued.ok_or(ReactorError::Shutdown)?;
312
                // Tell the relevant circuit padder that this cell is getting flushed.
313
                // Note that, technically, it won't go onto the network for a while longer:
314
                // it has to go through the TLS buffer, and the kernel TCP buffer.
315
                // We've got to live with that.
316
                // TODO: conceivably we could defer this even longer, but it would take
317
                // some tricky hacking!
318
                if let (Some(cell_padding_info), Some(circid)) = (cell_padding_info, msg.circid()) {
319
                    self.circs.note_cell_flushed(circid, cell_padding_info);
320
                }
321
                sendable.send(msg)?;
322
            }
323

            
324
            ret = self.control.next() => {
325
                let ctrl = match ret {
326
                    None | Some(CtrlMsg::Shutdown) => return Err(ReactorError::Shutdown),
327
                    Some(x) => x,
328
                };
329
                self.handle_control(ctrl).await?;
330
            }
331

            
332
            ret = self.padding_event_stream.next() => {
333
                let event = ret.ok_or_else(|| Error::from(internal!("Padding event stream was exhausted")))?;
334
                self.handle_padding_event(event).await?;
335
            }
336

            
337
            ret = self.input.next() => {
338
                let item = ret
339
                    .ok_or(ReactorError::Shutdown)??;
340
                crate::note_incoming_traffic();
341
                self.handle_cell(item).await?;
342
            }
343

            
344
        }
345
        Ok(()) // Run again.
346
5240
    }
347

            
348
    /// Handle a CtrlMsg other than Shutdown.
349
    #[instrument(level = "trace", skip(self))] // Intentionally omitting skip_all, msg is useful and not sensitive
350
110
    async fn handle_control(&mut self, msg: CtrlMsg) -> Result<()> {
351
        trace!(
352
            channel_id = %self,
353
            msg = ?msg,
354
            "reactor received control message"
355
        );
356

            
357
110
        match msg {
358
            CtrlMsg::Shutdown => panic!(), // was handled in reactor loop.
359
            CtrlMsg::CloseCircuit(id) => self.outbound_destroy_circ(id).await?,
360
            CtrlMsg::AllocateCircuit {
361
                created_sender,
362
                sender,
363
                tx,
364
            } => {
365
                let mut rng = rand::rng();
366
110
                let my_unique_id = self.unique_id;
367
                let circ_unique_id = self.circ_unique_id_ctx.next(my_unique_id);
368
                // NOTE: This is a very weird place to be calling new_padding, but:
369
                //  - we need to do it here or earlier, so we can add it as part of the CircEnt to
370
                //    our map.
371
                //  - We need to do it at some point where we have a runtime, which implies in a
372
                //    reactor.
373
                //
374
                // TODO circpad: We might want to lazy-allocate this somehow, or try harder to make
375
                // it a no-op when we aren't padding on a particular circuit.
376
                let (padding_ctrl, padding_stream) = crate::client::circuit::padding::new_padding(
377
                    // TODO: avoid using DynTimeProvider at some point, and re-parameterize for efficiency.
378
                    DynTimeProvider::new(self.runtime.clone()),
379
                );
380
                let ret: Result<_> = self
381
                    .circs
382
                    .add_ent(&mut rng, created_sender, sender, padding_ctrl.clone())
383
12
                    .map(|id| (id, circ_unique_id, padding_ctrl, padding_stream));
384
                let _ = tx.send(ret); // don't care about other side going away
385
                self.update_disused_since();
386
            }
387
            CtrlMsg::ConfigUpdate(updates) => {
388
                if self.link_protocol == 4 {
389
                    // Link protocol 4 does not permit sending, or negotiating, link padding.
390
                    // We test for == 4 so that future updates to handshake.rs LINK_PROTOCOLS
391
                    // keep doing padding things.
392
                    return Ok(());
393
                }
394

            
395
                let ChannelPaddingInstructionsUpdates {
396
                    // List all the fields explicitly; that way the compiler will warn us
397
                    // if one is added and we fail to handle it here.
398
                    padding_enable,
399
                    padding_parameters,
400
                    padding_negotiate,
401
                } = &*updates;
402
                if let Some(parameters) = padding_parameters {
403
                    self.padding_timer.as_mut().reconfigure(parameters)?;
404
                }
405
                if let Some(enable) = padding_enable {
406
                    if *enable {
407
                        self.padding_timer.as_mut().enable();
408
                    } else {
409
                        self.padding_timer.as_mut().disable();
410
                    }
411
                }
412
                if let Some(padding_negotiate) = padding_negotiate {
413
                    // This replaces any previous PADDING_NEGOTIATE cell that we were
414
                    // told to send, but which we didn't manage to send yet.
415
                    // It doesn't make sense to queue them up.
416
                    self.special_outgoing.padding_negotiate = Some(padding_negotiate.clone());
417
                }
418
            }
419
            CtrlMsg::KistConfigUpdate(kist) => self.apply_kist_params(&kist),
420
            #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding-manual")]
421
            CtrlMsg::SetChannelPadder { padder, sender } => {
422
                self.padding_ctrl
423
                    .install_padder_padding_at_hop(HopNum::from(0), padder);
424
                let _ignore = sender.send(Ok(()));
425
            }
426
        }
427
        Ok(())
428
110
    }
429

            
430
    /// Take the padding action described in `action`.
431
    ///
432
    /// (With circuit padding disabled, PaddingEvent can't be constructed.)
433
    #[cfg(not(feature = "circ-padding"))]
434
    #[allow(clippy::unused_async)] // for symmetry with the version below
435
    async fn handle_padding_event(&mut self, action: PaddingEvent) -> Result<()> {
436
        void::unreachable(action.0)
437
    }
438

            
439
    /// Take the padding action described in `action`.
440
    #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding")]
441
    async fn handle_padding_event(&mut self, action: PaddingEvent) -> Result<()> {
442
        use PaddingEvent as PE;
443
        match action {
444
            PE::SendPadding(send_padding) => {
445
                self.handle_send_padding(send_padding).await?;
446
            }
447
            PE::StartBlocking(start_blocking) => {
448
                if self.output.is_unlimited() {
449
                    self.output.set_blocked();
450
                }
451
                self.padding_blocker = Some(start_blocking);
452
            }
453
            PE::StopBlocking => {
454
                self.output.set_unlimited();
455
            }
456
        }
457
        Ok(())
458
    }
459

            
460
    /// Send the padding described in `padding`.
461
    #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding")]
462
    async fn handle_send_padding(&mut self, padding: SendPadding) -> Result<()> {
463
        // TODO circpad: This is somewhat duplicative of the logic in `Circuit::send_padding` and
464
        // `Circuit::padding_disposition`.  It might be good to unify them at some point.
465
        // For now (Oct 2025), though, they have slightly different inputs and behaviors.
466

            
467
        use crate::client::circuit::padding::{Bypass::*, Replace::*};
468
        // multihop padding belongs in circuit padders, not here.
469
        let hop = HopNum::from(0);
470
        assert_eq!(padding.hop, hop);
471

            
472
        // If true, there is blocking, but we are allowed to bypass it.
473
        let blocking_bypassed = matches!(
474
            (&self.padding_blocker, padding.may_bypass_block()),
475
            (
476
                Some(StartBlocking {
477
                    is_bypassable: true
478
                }),
479
                BypassBlocking
480
            )
481
        );
482
        // If true, there is blocking, and we can't bypass it.
483
        let this_padding_blocked = self.padding_blocker.is_some() && !blocking_bypassed;
484

            
485
        if padding.may_replace_with_data() == Replaceable {
486
            if self.output_is_full().await? {
487
                // When the output buffer is full,
488
                // we _always_ treat it as satisfying our replaceable padding.
489
                //
490
                // TODO circpad: It would be better to check whether
491
                // the output has any bytes at all, but futures_codec doesn't seem to give us a
492
                // way to check that.  If we manage to do so in the future, we should change the
493
                // logic in this function.
494
                self.padding_ctrl
495
                    .replaceable_padding_already_queued(hop, padding);
496
                return Ok(());
497
            } else if self.cells.approx_count() > 0 {
498
                // We can replace the padding with outbound cells!
499
                if this_padding_blocked {
500
                    // In the blocked case, we just declare that the pending data _is_ the queued padding.
501
                    self.padding_ctrl
502
                        .replaceable_padding_already_queued(hop, padding);
503
                } else {
504
                    // Otherwise we report that queued data _became_ padding,
505
                    // and we allow it to pass any blocking that's present.
506
                    self.padding_ctrl.queued_data_as_padding(hop, padding);
507
                    if blocking_bypassed {
508
                        self.output.allow_n_additional_items(1);
509
                    }
510
                }
511
                return Ok(());
512
            } else {
513
                // There's nothing to replace this with, so fall through.
514
            }
515
        }
516

            
517
        // There's no replacement, so we queue unconditionally.
518
        self.special_outgoing.queue_padding_cell();
519
        self.padding_ctrl.queued_padding(hop, padding);
520
        if blocking_bypassed {
521
            self.output.allow_n_additional_items(1);
522
        }
523

            
524
        Ok(())
525
    }
526

            
527
    /// Return true if the output stream is full.
528
    ///
529
    /// We use this in circuit padding to implement replaceable padding.
530
    //
531
    // TODO circpad: We'd rather check whether there is any data at all queued in self.output,
532
    // but futures_codec doesn't give us a way to do that.
533
    #[cfg(feature = "circ-padding")]
534
    async fn output_is_full(&mut self) -> Result<bool> {
535
        use futures::future::poll_fn;
536
        use std::task::Poll;
537
        // We use poll_fn to get a cx that we can pass to poll_ready_unpin.
538
        poll_fn(|cx| {
539
            Poll::Ready(match self.output.poll_ready_unpin(cx) {
540
                // If if's ready to send, it isn't full.
541
                Poll::Ready(Ok(())) => Ok(false),
542
                // If it isn't ready to send, it's full.
543
                Poll::Pending => Ok(true),
544
                // Propagate errors:
545
                Poll::Ready(Err(e)) => Err(e),
546
            })
547
        })
548
        .await
549
    }
550

            
551
    /// Helper: process a cell on a channel.  Most cell types get ignored
552
    /// or rejected; a few get delivered to circuits.
553
    #[instrument(level = "trace", skip_all)]
554
432
    async fn handle_cell(&mut self, cell: AnyChanCell) -> Result<()> {
555
        let (circid, msg) = cell.into_circid_and_msg();
556
        use AnyChanMsg::*;
557

            
558
        match msg {
559
            Relay(_) | Padding(_) | Vpadding(_) => {} // too frequent to log.
560
            _ => trace!(
561
                channel_id = %self,
562
                "received {} for {}",
563
                msg.cmd(),
564
                CircId::get_or_zero(circid)
565
            ),
566
        }
567

            
568
        // Report the message to the padding controller.
569
        match msg {
570
            Padding(_) | Vpadding(_) => {
571
                // We always accept channel padding, even if we haven't negotiated any.
572
                let _always_acceptable = self.padding_ctrl.decrypted_padding(HopNum::from(0));
573
            }
574
            _ => self.padding_ctrl.decrypted_data(HopNum::from(0)),
575
        }
576

            
577
        match msg {
578
            // These are allowed, and need to be handled.
579
            Relay(_) => self.deliver_relay(circid, msg).await,
580

            
581
            Destroy(_) => self.deliver_destroy(circid, msg).await,
582

            
583
            CreatedFast(_) | Created2(_) => self.deliver_created(circid, msg),
584

            
585
            // These are always ignored.
586
            Padding(_) | Vpadding(_) => Ok(()),
587
            _ => Err(Error::ChanProto(format!("Unexpected cell: {msg:?}"))),
588
        }
589
432
    }
590

            
591
    /// Give the RELAY cell `msg` to the appropriate circuit.
592
360
    async fn deliver_relay(&mut self, circid: Option<CircId>, msg: AnyChanMsg) -> Result<()> {
593
360
        let Some(circid) = circid else {
594
            return Err(Error::ChanProto("Relay cell without circuit ID".into()));
595
        };
596

            
597
360
        let mut ent = self
598
360
            .circs
599
360
            .get_mut(circid)
600
360
            .ok_or_else(|| Error::ChanProto("Relay cell on nonexistent circuit".into()))?;
601

            
602
336
        match &mut *ent {
603
12
            CircEnt::Open { cell_sender: s, .. } => {
604
                // There's an open circuit; we can give it the RELAY cell.
605
12
                if s.send(msg).await.is_err() {
606
                    drop(ent);
607
                    // The circuit's receiver went away, so we should destroy the circuit.
608
                    self.outbound_destroy_circ(circid).await?;
609
12
                }
610
12
                Ok(())
611
            }
612
12
            CircEnt::Opening { .. } => Err(Error::ChanProto(
613
12
                "Relay cell on pending circuit before CREATED* received".into(),
614
12
            )),
615
312
            CircEnt::DestroySent(hs) => hs.receive_cell(),
616
        }
617
360
    }
618

            
619
    /// Handle a CREATED{,_FAST,2} cell by passing it on to the appropriate
620
    /// circuit, if that circuit is waiting for one.
621
24
    fn deliver_created(&mut self, circid: Option<CircId>, msg: AnyChanMsg) -> Result<()> {
622
24
        let Some(circid) = circid else {
623
            return Err(Error::ChanProto("'Created' cell without circuit ID".into()));
624
        };
625

            
626
24
        let target = self.circs.advance_from_opening(circid)?;
627
        let created = msg.try_into()?;
628
        // TODO(nickm) I think that this one actually means the other side
629
        // is closed. See arti#269.
630
        target.send(created).map_err(|_| {
631
            Error::from(internal!(
632
                "Circuit queue rejected created message. Is it closing?"
633
            ))
634
        })
635
24
    }
636

            
637
    /// Handle a DESTROY cell by removing the corresponding circuit
638
    /// from the map, and passing the destroy cell onward to the circuit.
639
48
    async fn deliver_destroy(&mut self, circid: Option<CircId>, msg: AnyChanMsg) -> Result<()> {
640
48
        let Some(circid) = circid else {
641
            return Err(Error::ChanProto("'Destroy' cell without circuit ID".into()));
642
        };
643

            
644
        // Remove the circuit from the map: nothing more can be done with it.
645
48
        let entry = self.circs.remove(circid);
646
48
        self.update_disused_since();
647
36
        match entry {
648
            // If the circuit is waiting for CREATED, tell it that it
649
            // won't get one.
650
            Some(CircEnt::Opening {
651
12
                create_response_sender,
652
                ..
653
            }) => {
654
12
                trace!(channel_id = %self, "Passing destroy to pending circuit {}", circid);
655
12
                create_response_sender
656
12
                    .send(msg.try_into()?)
657
                    // TODO(nickm) I think that this one actually means the other side
658
                    // is closed. See arti#269.
659
12
                    .map_err(|_| {
660
                        internal!("pending circuit wasn't interested in destroy cell?").into()
661
                    })
662
            }
663
            // It's an open circuit: tell it that it got a DESTROY cell.
664
            Some(CircEnt::Open {
665
12
                mut cell_sender, ..
666
            }) => {
667
12
                trace!(channel_id = %self, "Passing destroy to open circuit {}", circid);
668
12
                cell_sender
669
12
                    .send(msg)
670
12
                    .await
671
                    // TODO(nickm) I think that this one actually means the other side
672
                    // is closed. See arti#269.
673
12
                    .map_err(|_| {
674
                        internal!("open circuit wasn't interested in destroy cell?").into()
675
                    })
676
            }
677
            // We've sent a destroy; we can leave this circuit removed.
678
12
            Some(CircEnt::DestroySent(_)) => Ok(()),
679
            // Got a DESTROY cell for a circuit we don't have.
680
            None => {
681
12
                trace!(channel_id = %self, "Destroy for nonexistent circuit {}", circid);
682
12
                Err(Error::ChanProto("Destroy for nonexistent circuit".into()))
683
            }
684
        }
685
48
    }
686

            
687
    /// Helper: send a cell on the outbound sink.
688
98
    async fn send_cell(&mut self, cell: AnyChanCell) -> Result<()> {
689
98
        self.output.send(cell).await?;
690
66
        Ok(())
691
98
    }
692

            
693
    /// Called when a circuit goes away: sends a DESTROY cell and removes
694
    /// the circuit.
695
98
    async fn outbound_destroy_circ(&mut self, id: CircId) -> Result<()> {
696
98
        trace!(channel_id = %self, "Circuit {} is gone; sending DESTROY", id);
697
        // Remove the circuit's entry from the map: nothing more
698
        // can be done with it.
699
        // TODO: It would be great to have a tighter upper bound for
700
        // the number of relay cells we'll receive.
701
98
        self.circs.destroy_sent(id, HalfCirc::new(3000));
702
98
        self.update_disused_since();
703
98
        let destroy = Destroy::new(DestroyReason::NONE).into();
704
98
        let cell = AnyChanCell::new(Some(id), destroy);
705
98
        self.send_cell(cell).await?;
706

            
707
66
        Ok(())
708
98
    }
709

            
710
    /// Update disused timestamp with current time if this channel is no longer used
711
158
    fn update_disused_since(&self) {
712
158
        if self.circs.open_ent_count() == 0 {
713
146
            // Update disused_since if it still indicates that the channel is in use
714
146
            self.details.unused_since.update_if_none();
715
146
        } else {
716
12
            // Mark this channel as in use
717
12
            self.details.unused_since.clear();
718
12
        }
719
158
    }
720

            
721
    /// Use the new KIST parameters.
722
    #[cfg(target_os = "linux")]
723
    fn apply_kist_params(&self, params: &KistParams) {
724
        use super::kist::KistMode;
725

            
726
        let set_tcp_notsent_lowat = |v: u32| {
727
            if let Err(e) = self.streamops.set_tcp_notsent_lowat(v) {
728
                // This is bad, but not fatal: not setting the KIST options
729
                // comes with a performance penalty, but we don't have to crash.
730
                error_report!(e, "Failed to set KIST socket options");
731
            }
732
        };
733

            
734
        match params.kist_enabled() {
735
            KistMode::TcpNotSentLowat => set_tcp_notsent_lowat(params.tcp_notsent_lowat()),
736
            KistMode::Disabled => set_tcp_notsent_lowat(u32::MAX),
737
        }
738
    }
739

            
740
    /// Use the new KIST parameters.
741
    #[cfg(not(target_os = "linux"))]
742
    fn apply_kist_params(&self, params: &KistParams) {
743
        use super::kist::KistMode;
744

            
745
        if params.kist_enabled() != KistMode::Disabled {
746
            tracing::warn!("KIST not currently supported on non-linux platforms");
747
        }
748
    }
749
}
750

            
751
#[cfg(test)]
752
pub(crate) mod test {
753
    #![allow(clippy::unwrap_used)]
754
    use super::*;
755
    use crate::channel::{Canonicity, ChannelType, ClosedUnexpectedly, UniqId};
756
    use crate::client::circuit::CircParameters;
757
    use crate::client::circuit::padding::new_padding;
758
    use crate::fake_mpsc;
759
    use crate::peer::PeerInfo;
760
    use crate::util::{DummyTimeoutEstimator, fake_mq};
761
    use futures::sink::SinkExt;
762
    use futures::stream::StreamExt;
763
    use tor_cell::chancell::msg;
764
    use tor_linkspec::OwnedChanTarget;
765
    use tor_rtcompat::SpawnExt;
766
    use tor_rtcompat::{DynTimeProvider, NoOpStreamOpsHandle, Runtime};
767

            
768
    pub(crate) type CodecResult = std::result::Result<AnyChanCell, Error>;
769

            
770
    pub(crate) fn new_reactor<R: Runtime>(
771
        runtime: R,
772
    ) -> (
773
        Arc<crate::channel::Channel>,
774
        Reactor<R>,
775
        mpsc::Receiver<AnyChanCell>,
776
        mpsc::Sender<CodecResult>,
777
    ) {
778
        let link_protocol = 4;
779
        let (send1, recv1) = mpsc::channel(32);
780
        let (send2, recv2) = mpsc::channel(32);
781
        let unique_id = UniqId::new();
782
        let dummy_target = OwnedChanTarget::builder()
783
            .ed_identity([6; 32].into())
784
            .rsa_identity([10; 20].into())
785
            .build()
786
            .unwrap();
787
        let send1 = send1.sink_map_err(|e| {
788
            trace!("got sink error: {:?}", e);
789
            Error::CellDecodeErr {
790
                object: "reactor test",
791
                err: tor_cell::Error::ChanProto("dummy message".into()),
792
            }
793
        });
794
        let stream_ops = NoOpStreamOpsHandle::default();
795
        let (chan, reactor) = crate::channel::Channel::new(
796
            ChannelType::ClientInitiator,
797
            link_protocol,
798
            Box::new(send1),
799
            Box::new(recv2),
800
            Box::new(stream_ops),
801
            unique_id,
802
            dummy_target,
803
            safelog::MaybeSensitive::not_sensitive(PeerInfo::EMPTY),
804
            crate::ClockSkew::None,
805
            runtime,
806
            fake_mq(),
807
            Canonicity::new_canonical(),
808
        )
809
        .expect("channel create failed");
810
        (chan, reactor, recv1, send2)
811
    }
812

            
813
    // Try shutdown from inside run_once..
814
    #[test]
815
    fn shutdown() {
816
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
817
            let (chan, mut reactor, _output, _input) = new_reactor(rt);
818

            
819
            chan.terminate();
820
            let r = reactor.run_once().await;
821
            assert!(matches!(r, Err(ReactorError::Shutdown)));
822
        });
823
    }
824

            
825
    // Try shutdown while reactor is running.
826
    #[test]
827
    fn shutdown2() {
828
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
829
            // TODO: Ask a rust person if this is how to do this.
830

            
831
            use futures::future::FutureExt;
832
            use futures::join;
833

            
834
            let (chan, reactor, _output, _input) = new_reactor(rt);
835
            // Let's get the reactor running...
836
            let run_reactor = reactor.run().map(|x| x.is_ok()).shared();
837

            
838
            let rr = run_reactor.clone();
839

            
840
            let exit_then_check = async {
841
                assert!(rr.peek().is_none());
842
                // ... and terminate the channel while that's happening.
843
                chan.terminate();
844
            };
845

            
846
            let (rr_s, _) = join!(run_reactor, exit_then_check);
847

            
848
            // Now let's see. The reactor should not _still_ be running.
849
            assert!(rr_s);
850
        });
851
    }
852

            
853
    #[test]
854
    fn new_circ_closed() {
855
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
856
            let (chan, mut reactor, mut output, _input) = new_reactor(rt.clone());
857
            assert!(chan.duration_unused().is_some()); // unused yet
858

            
859
            let (ret, reac) = futures::join!(
860
                chan.new_tunnel(Arc::new(DummyTimeoutEstimator)),
861
                reactor.run_once()
862
            );
863
            let (pending, circr) = ret.unwrap();
864
            rt.spawn(async {
865
                let _ignore = circr.run().await;
866
            })
867
            .unwrap();
868
            assert!(reac.is_ok());
869

            
870
            let id = pending.peek_circid();
871

            
872
            let ent = reactor.circs.get_mut(id);
873
            assert!(matches!(*ent.unwrap(), CircEnt::Opening { .. }));
874
            assert!(chan.duration_unused().is_none()); // in use
875

            
876
            // Now drop the circuit; this should tell the reactor to remove
877
            // the circuit from the map.
878
            drop(pending);
879

            
880
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
881
            let ent = reactor.circs.get_mut(id);
882
            assert!(matches!(*ent.unwrap(), CircEnt::DestroySent(_)));
883
            let cell = output.next().await.unwrap();
884
            assert_eq!(cell.circid(), Some(id));
885
            assert!(matches!(cell.msg(), AnyChanMsg::Destroy(_)));
886
            assert!(chan.duration_unused().is_some()); // unused again
887
        });
888
    }
889

            
890
    // Test proper delivery of a created cell that doesn't make a channel
891
    #[test]
892
    #[ignore] // See bug #244: re-enable this test once it passes reliably.
893
    fn new_circ_create_failure() {
894
        use std::time::Duration;
895
        use tor_rtcompat::SleepProvider;
896

            
897
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
898
            let (chan, mut reactor, mut output, mut input) = new_reactor(rt.clone());
899

            
900
            let (ret, reac) = futures::join!(
901
                chan.new_tunnel(Arc::new(DummyTimeoutEstimator)),
902
                reactor.run_once()
903
            );
904
            let (pending, circr) = ret.unwrap();
905
            rt.spawn(async {
906
                let _ignore = circr.run().await;
907
            })
908
            .unwrap();
909
            assert!(reac.is_ok());
910

            
911
            let circparams = CircParameters::default();
912

            
913
            let id = pending.peek_circid();
914

            
915
            let ent = reactor.circs.get_mut(id);
916
            assert!(matches!(*ent.unwrap(), CircEnt::Opening { .. }));
917

            
918
            #[allow(clippy::clone_on_copy)]
919
            let rtc = rt.clone();
920
            let send_response = async {
921
                rtc.sleep(Duration::from_millis(100)).await;
922
                trace!("sending createdfast");
923
                // We'll get a bad handshake result from this createdfast cell.
924
                let created_cell = AnyChanCell::new(Some(id), msg::CreatedFast::new(*b"x").into());
925
                input.send(Ok(created_cell)).await.unwrap();
926
                reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
927
            };
928

            
929
            let (circ, _) = futures::join!(pending.create_firsthop_fast(circparams), send_response);
930
            // Make sure statuses are as expected.
931
            assert!(matches!(circ.err().unwrap(), Error::BadCircHandshakeAuth));
932

            
933
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
934

            
935
            // Make sure that the createfast cell got sent
936
            let cell_sent = output.next().await.unwrap();
937
            assert!(matches!(cell_sent.msg(), msg::AnyChanMsg::CreateFast(_)));
938

            
939
            // But the next run if the reactor will make the circuit get closed.
940
            let ent = reactor.circs.get_mut(id);
941
            assert!(matches!(*ent.unwrap(), CircEnt::DestroySent(_)));
942
        });
943
    }
944

            
945
    // Try incoming cells that shouldn't arrive on channels.
946
    #[test]
947
    fn bad_cells() {
948
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
949
            let (_chan, mut reactor, _output, mut input) = new_reactor(rt);
950

            
951
            // shouldn't get created2 cells for nonexistent circuits
952
            let created2_cell = msg::Created2::new(*b"hihi").into();
953
            input
954
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(7), created2_cell)))
955
                .await
956
                .unwrap();
957

            
958
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
959
            assert_eq!(
960
                format!("{}", e),
961
                "Channel protocol violation: Unexpected CREATED* cell not on opening circuit"
962
            );
963

            
964
            // Can't get a relay cell on a circuit we've never heard of.
965
            let relay_cell = msg::Relay::new(b"abc").into();
966
            input
967
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(4), relay_cell)))
968
                .await
969
                .unwrap();
970
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
971
            assert_eq!(
972
                format!("{}", e),
973
                "Channel protocol violation: Relay cell on nonexistent circuit"
974
            );
975

            
976
            // There used to be tests here for other types, but now that we only
977
            // accept OpenClientChanCell, we know that the codec can't even try
978
            // to give us e.g. VERSIONS or CREATE.
979
        });
980
    }
981

            
982
    #[test]
983
    fn deliver_relay() {
984
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
985
            use oneshot_fused_workaround as oneshot;
986

            
987
            let (_chan, mut reactor, _output, mut input) = new_reactor(rt.clone());
988

            
989
            let (padding_ctrl, _padding_stream) = new_padding(DynTimeProvider::new(rt));
990

            
991
            let (_circ_stream_7, mut circ_stream_13) = {
992
                let (snd1, _rcv1) = oneshot::channel();
993
                let (snd2, rcv2) = fake_mpsc(64);
994
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
995
                    CircId::new(7).unwrap(),
996
                    CircEnt::Opening {
997
                        create_response_sender: snd1,
998
                        cell_sender: snd2,
999
                        padding_ctrl: padding_ctrl.clone(),
                    },
                );
                let (snd3, rcv3) = fake_mpsc(64);
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
                    CircId::new(13).unwrap(),
                    CircEnt::Open {
                        cell_sender: snd3,
                        padding_ctrl,
                    },
                );
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
                    CircId::new(23).unwrap(),
                    CircEnt::DestroySent(HalfCirc::new(25)),
                );
                (rcv2, rcv3)
            };
            // If a relay cell is sent on an open channel, the correct circuit
            // should get it.
            let relaycell: AnyChanMsg = msg::Relay::new(b"do you suppose").into();
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(13), relaycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
            let got = circ_stream_13.next().await.unwrap();
            assert!(matches!(got, AnyChanMsg::Relay(_)));
            // If a relay cell is sent on an opening channel, that's an error.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(7), relaycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
            assert_eq!(
                format!("{}", e),
                "Channel protocol violation: Relay cell on pending circuit before CREATED* received"
            );
            // If a relay cell is sent on a non-existent channel, that's an error.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(101), relaycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
            assert_eq!(
                format!("{}", e),
                "Channel protocol violation: Relay cell on nonexistent circuit"
            );
            // It's fine to get a relay cell on a DestroySent channel: that happens
            // when the other side hasn't noticed the Destroy yet.
            // We can do this 25 more times according to our setup:
            for _ in 0..25 {
                input
                    .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(23), relaycell.clone())))
                    .await
                    .unwrap();
                reactor.run_once().await.unwrap(); // should be fine.
            }
            // This one will fail.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(23), relaycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
            assert_eq!(
                format!("{}", e),
                "Channel protocol violation: Too many cells received on destroyed circuit"
            );
        });
    }
    #[test]
    fn deliver_destroy() {
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
            use crate::circuit::celltypes::*;
            use oneshot_fused_workaround as oneshot;
            let (_chan, mut reactor, _output, mut input) = new_reactor(rt.clone());
            let (padding_ctrl, _padding_stream) = new_padding(DynTimeProvider::new(rt));
            let (circ_oneshot_7, mut circ_stream_13) = {
                let (snd1, rcv1) = oneshot::channel();
                let (snd2, _rcv2) = fake_mpsc(64);
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
                    CircId::new(7).unwrap(),
                    CircEnt::Opening {
                        create_response_sender: snd1,
                        cell_sender: snd2,
                        padding_ctrl: padding_ctrl.clone(),
                    },
                );
                let (snd3, rcv3) = fake_mpsc(64);
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
                    CircId::new(13).unwrap(),
                    CircEnt::Open {
                        cell_sender: snd3,
                        padding_ctrl: padding_ctrl.clone(),
                    },
                );
                reactor.circs.put_unchecked(
                    CircId::new(23).unwrap(),
                    CircEnt::DestroySent(HalfCirc::new(25)),
                );
                (rcv1, rcv3)
            };
            // Destroying an opening circuit is fine.
            let destroycell: AnyChanMsg = msg::Destroy::new(0.into()).into();
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(7), destroycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
            let msg = circ_oneshot_7.await;
            assert!(matches!(msg, Ok(CreateResponse::Destroy(_))));
            // Destroying an open circuit is fine.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(13), destroycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
            let msg = circ_stream_13.next().await.unwrap();
            assert!(matches!(msg, AnyChanMsg::Destroy(_)));
            // Destroying a DestroySent circuit is fine.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(23), destroycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            reactor.run_once().await.unwrap();
            // Destroying a nonexistent circuit is an error.
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(101), destroycell.clone())))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            let e = reactor.run_once().await.unwrap_err().unwrap_err();
            assert_eq!(
                format!("{}", e),
                "Channel protocol violation: Destroy for nonexistent circuit"
            );
        });
    }
    #[test]
    fn closing_if_reactor_dropped() {
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
            let (chan, reactor, _output, _input) = new_reactor(rt);
            assert!(!chan.is_closing());
            drop(reactor);
            assert!(chan.is_closing());
            assert!(matches!(
                chan.wait_for_close().await,
                Err(ClosedUnexpectedly::ReactorDropped),
            ));
        });
    }
    #[test]
    fn closing_if_reactor_shutdown() {
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
            let (chan, reactor, _output, _input) = new_reactor(rt);
            assert!(!chan.is_closing());
            chan.terminate();
            assert!(!chan.is_closing());
            let r = reactor.run().await;
            assert!(r.is_ok());
            assert!(chan.is_closing());
            assert!(chan.wait_for_close().await.is_ok());
        });
    }
    #[test]
    fn reactor_error_wait_for_close() {
        tor_rtcompat::test_with_all_runtimes!(|rt| async move {
            let (chan, reactor, _output, mut input) = new_reactor(rt);
            // force an error by sending created2 cell for nonexistent circuit
            let created2_cell = msg::Created2::new(*b"hihi").into();
            input
                .send(Ok(AnyChanCell::new(CircId::new(7), created2_cell)))
                .await
                .unwrap();
            // `reactor.run()` should return an error
            let run_error = reactor.run().await.unwrap_err();
            // `chan.wait_for_close()` should return the same error
            let Err(ClosedUnexpectedly::ReactorError(wait_error)) = chan.wait_for_close().await
            else {
                panic!("Expected a 'ReactorError'");
            };
            // `Error` doesn't implement `PartialEq`, so best we can do is to compare the strings
            assert_eq!(run_error.to_string(), wait_error.to_string());
        });
    }
}